Gaspar Szilagyi, S (2019) The Uneasy Relationship between Intra-EU Investment Tribunals and the Court of Justice’s Achmea Judgment. European Investment Law and Arbitration Review. ISSN 2468-9017

[thumbnail of 2019. Gaspar and Usynin. EILAR.pdf]
2019. Gaspar and Usynin. EILAR.pdf - Accepted Version

Download (746kB) | Preview


This paper focuses on the ways in which investment tribunals constituted under intra-EU BITs and the Energy Charter Treaty (in an intra-EU dispute) have reacted to the Court of Justice’s Achmea judgment of 6 March 2018. The first part of the paper maps out the existing intra-EU arbitrations in which the issues arising from Achmea appear in one form or another. We then take a critical look at how the disputing parties have used Achmea in their argumentation and how the investment tribunals have dismissed these arguments and upheld their jurisdiction. The second part of the paper is analytical. When the tribunals uphold their jurisdiction and decide on the merits, they knowingly deliver an award, which is unenforceable in the Respondent State and the entirety of the EU. By drawing parallels with decisions rendered by other international tribunals, we argue that the rendering of potentially unenforceable awards is not specific to intra-EU investment disputes. We then look at why international tribunals render potentially unenforceable awards. The third part of the paper presents several suggestions of how intra-EU investment tribunals should tackle the Achmea conundrum, either by declining their jurisdiction pursuant to judicial comity or upholding their jurisdiction but dismissing the cases as inadmissible.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: foreign direct investment, Achmea, European Court of Justice, intra-EU investment treaty arbitration, enforcement of arbitral awards, admissibility, compliance, judicial comity
Subjects: H Social Sciences > HF Commerce
K Law > KZ Law of Nations
Divisions: Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences > School of Law
Depositing User: Symplectic
Date Deposited: 22 Nov 2019 11:20
Last Modified: 22 Mar 2021 12:55

Actions (login required)

View Item
View Item